R.E.M.’s Reveal turns 25. Which edition has the Paris set and which has surround sound?
The new double LP captures a 17-song show recorded days before Reveal came out. The deluxe Blu-ray gives the studio album a different kind of second listen.
On R.E.M.’s Reveal, “Imitation of Life” is track eight. At the band’s May 7, 2001 performance for Radio France in Paris, it was the opening number. Both recordings are out together on November 20 for the album’s 25th anniversary. The wrinkle for anyone looking at the pink sleeves is that the new double LP contains the Paris show. To hear the studio record and the radio set back to back, the expanded digital edition or the two-CD set is the place to start.
A running order from before the album came out
Radio France recorded the band just days before Reveal went on sale. R.E.M. played a handful of promotional dates around the release, according to Craft Recordings. There was no conventional album tour, which makes this 17-song set an unusually useful record of the band’s choices that spring. The band could put a new song up front, but most of the audience had yet to hear how it sat within the album. The track list tells you something about that decision without asking you to take anybody’s word for how the room sounded.
On the record, “The Lifting” leads straight into “I’ve Been High”. In Paris, R.E.M. separated them, slipping the older “Electrolite” between the two and playing “The Lifting” second of the pair. On the way from the opening single to the closing “It’s the End of the World as We Know It (And I Feel Fine)”, they made room for “The One I Love” and “Losing My Religion”. The band’s vinyl track listing preserves that order across four sides. An owner of the 2001 album can add the complete Paris performance that way without buying the studio recording again.
Where the surround mix lives
| Edition | What you can play |
|---|---|
| Expanded digital album | The 12 studio tracks followed by the 17 Paris performances |
| The Black Sessions Revealed, two LPs | The entire Paris set across four sides |
| Two CDs and Blu-ray | The album on one CD, the Paris set on the other, plus the studio album in high-resolution and 5.1 audio on Blu-ray |
The deluxe set’s disc list is worth reading literally. Its 5.1 mix belongs to the studio album. That matters when choosing what to play through a surround system. The radio session has its own CD, while the Blu-ray also holds three music videos and the original electronic press kit. One of the videos gives “Imitation of Life” a third setting altogether. Director Garth Jennings turned about twenty seconds of a pool party into a four-minute sequence, repeatedly directing attention to another part of the same scene. Craft Recordings’ account of the videos
Collectors comparing pressings sometimes find that the price or colour changes while every track stays put. Here the decisive detail is the title on the sleeve. If the attraction is hearing what R.E.M. played for Paris before most listeners had even bought Reveal, look for The Black Sessions Revealed. You'll know you have the right recording as soon as track eight starts playing first.