Edward Kenway overlooks a Caribbean harbour in Assassin’s Creed Black Flag Resynced.
Culture / The story

Black Flag beat Ubisoft’s forecast. Why did quarterly bookings fall 21%?

Premium editions of the Assassin’s Creed remake sold better than expected. A look at last summer’s partnership deals explains why the publisher still came up short year on year.

GeekRadar3 min read

A pirate who first sailed in 2013 helped Ubisoft beat its quarterly forecast by roughly €19 million. The French publisher singled out Assassin’s Creed Black Flag Resynced when it reported its results on November 19. The remake sold a richer mix of editions than Ubisoft had expected. Yet across the company, net bookings for the quarter fell from €490.8 million a year earlier to €388.9 million. How can both things be true? One comparison measures the summer Ubisoft had planned for. The other reaches back to a summer when it had different deals on the books.

What a premium edition changes

When two people buy Black Flag Resynced, their purchases needn't contribute the same amount. The Standard and Deluxe editions share the campaign. Deluxe adds gear for Edward Kenway and fittings for his ship, down to a pet and a wheel. If more buyers choose that package than a publisher budgeted for, the value of its sales can exceed the forecast even with the same number of copies sold.

Ubisoft cited both the share of premium editions and spending inside the game. It also credited the wider catalogue for part of the quarter’s performance. The €19 million difference measures how far the whole company finished above its guidance of about €370 million. Treating that difference as the remake’s sales would assign the performance of every other game and agreement to one ship.

Ubisoft’s fiscal second-quarter net bookings fell from €490.8 million to €388.9 million, including partnerships in both periods.
Ubisoft’s fiscal second-quarter net bookings fell from €490.8 million to €388.9 million, including partnerships in both periods.

The part of last summer that a remake couldn't repeat

The starkest change was in the back catalogue. Those bookings came to roughly €218 million in the quarter, down 55% year on year. In the corresponding period last year, Ubisoft had both a substantial contribution from Assassin’s Creed Shadows and partnership deals. Strip out partnerships on both sides and the back-catalogue decline shrinks to a high single-digit percentage, according to chief financial officer Frédérick Duguet’s earnings call. Apply the same exclusion to the full quarterly business, including new releases, and bookings actually grew more than 50%.

That last figure is worth reading alongside the reported decline. Partnerships are real business for Ubisoft. Removing them helps isolate how the rest of its business performed, but the money those agreements brought in last year still has to be replaced. A remake can sell better than its publisher anticipated without filling that gap.

Ubisoft expects about €250 million in bookings in the following quarter, citing a lighter release schedule and competition over the holidays, Reuters reported. Existing owners have meanwhile gained a reason to return through Black Flag’s New Game Plus. A returning captain can spend another evening on the Jackdaw without buying a second copy. That distinction matters as Ubisoft heads into a quieter release calendar. Keeping a favourite game in rotation and replacing last year’s partnership income are two quite different jobs.